How a harbor-front revitalization anchored its public realm with a splash pad as public-private partnership
A composite harbor-front-revitalization case study of a major waterfront harbor-front revitalization initiative whose public-realm anchor splash pad was developed through a structured public-private partnership across the city, the port authority, a master-developer partnership, and the broader harbor-front-revitalization stakeholder coalition.
Summary
A major waterfront harbor-front revitalization initiative anchored on Lake Erie's North Coast Harbor district adjacent to downtown Cleveland — a roughly 28-acre harbor-front revitalization integrating retained cultural and tourism anchors (the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the Great Lakes Science Center, the Cleveland Browns Stadium) with new mixed-use residential, hospitality, retail, and public-realm infrastructure under a structured public-private partnership across the City of Cleveland, the Cleveland-Cuyahoga County Port Authority, a master-developer partnership, and the broader harbor-front-revitalization stakeholder coalition — anchored its public realm with a $475,000 splash pad explicitly scoped as integrated public-realm anchor infrastructure for the broader harbor-front revitalization. The pad operates as anchor public-realm infrastructure across the harbor-front public-realm portfolio with structured family-amenity programming during operating-season windows, integrated programming with adjacent cultural-anchor infrastructure including the Rock Hall and Science Center, and broader public-realm-anchor programming across the broader harbor-front-revitalization context. The capital structure combined a U.S. Economic Development Administration (EDA) waterfront-redevelopment capital pathway, a state Ohio Department of Development capital appropriation, a Cleveland-Cuyahoga County Port Authority capital pathway, and a master-developer capital contribution through the broader public-private partnership infrastructure.
Key metrics
Background: a harbor-front revitalization and a public-realm-anchor opportunity
North Coast Harbor is a roughly 28-acre Lake Erie harbor-front district adjacent to downtown Cleveland, integrating retained cultural and tourism anchors including the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the Great Lakes Science Center, and the Cleveland Browns Stadium with new mixed-use residential, hospitality, retail, and public-realm infrastructure under a structured harbor-front revitalization initiative. The revitalization operates under a structured public-private partnership across the City of Cleveland, the Cleveland-Cuyahoga County Port Authority, a master-developer partnership, and the broader harbor-front-revitalization stakeholder coalition including downtown-Cleveland-stakeholder infrastructure, broader Lake Erie waterfront stakeholder infrastructure, and broader regional waterfront-redevelopment stakeholder infrastructure. The revitalization's public-realm framework operates as the structural connective infrastructure across the broader harbor-front revitalization, integrating retained cultural-anchor infrastructure with new mixed-use development through structured public-realm pedestrian-flow infrastructure, structured public-realm programming infrastructure, and broader public-realm visitor-experience infrastructure. By 2022, the master-developer partnership in coordination with the City of Cleveland and the Port Authority had identified a substantial public-realm-anchor opportunity, with the broader public-realm framework demonstrating substantial public-realm-anchor amenity potential and the proposed harbor-front public-realm anchor offering structured opportunity for integrated public-realm amenity scoping.
Public-private partnership scoping: harbor-front public-realm anchor framework and stakeholder coalition governance
The defining scoping framework of the project is structured public-private partnership scoping reflecting the broader harbor-front-revitalization public-private partnership infrastructure. Public-private partnership governance operates through structured governance infrastructure across the City of Cleveland, the Cleveland-Cuyahoga County Port Authority, the master-developer partnership, and the broader harbor-front-revitalization stakeholder coalition with structured P3 governance frameworks supporting integrated capital-structuring, operational-programming, and broader public-realm-anchor governance dimensions. Harbor-front public-realm anchor framework operates with the splash pad scoped as anchor public-realm infrastructure across the broader harbor-front public-realm portfolio, with structured pedestrian-flow integration connecting the pad-anchor area to adjacent cultural-anchor infrastructure including the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and the Great Lakes Science Center, structured public-realm programming integration across the broader harbor-front public-realm context, and broader public-realm-anchor visitor-experience integration. Stakeholder coalition governance operates through structured stakeholder-coalition governance infrastructure including the broader harbor-front-revitalization stakeholder coalition, broader downtown-Cleveland-stakeholder infrastructure, broader Lake Erie waterfront stakeholder infrastructure, and broader regional waterfront-redevelopment stakeholder infrastructure with structured stakeholder-coalition consultation across every scoping decision. The public-private partnership scoping framework was developed in extensive coordination with all P3 stakeholders across an extended engagement period predating capital scoping.
Capital structure: EDA waterfront-redevelopment, state development capital, port authority, and master-developer P3 contribution
The $475,000 construction cost was funded through a four-source capital structure deliberately calibrated across the public-private partnership scoping framework. The U.S. Economic Development Administration (EDA) waterfront-redevelopment capital pathway contributed $175,000 through EDA's broader waterfront-redevelopment capital infrastructure, with EDA program staff explicitly citing the project as a strong demonstration of integrated waterfront-redevelopment public-realm-anchor infrastructure within harbor-front revitalization contexts. A state Ohio Department of Development capital appropriation contributed $135,000 through the broader state economic-development capital pathway, with state economic-development leadership citing the project's broader harbor-front-revitalization scope dimension and the structurally significant Cleveland-and-Lake-Erie regional development integration. The Cleveland-Cuyahoga County Port Authority contributed $90,000 through the broader port-authority capital infrastructure, with port-authority leadership citing the project's broader harbor-front-revitalization integration and the structurally significant port-authority public-realm scope dimension. The master-developer partnership contributed $75,000 through the broader public-private partnership capital infrastructure, with master-developer leadership citing the project's broader public-realm-anchor integration with the master-developer partnership's broader harbor-front-revitalization development portfolio. The capital-structure design deliberately balanced contributions across pathways aligned with the public-private partnership scoping framework.
Programming integration: harbor-front public-realm, cultural-anchor partnership, and broader downtown-Cleveland programming
The pad operates as integrated programming infrastructure across the harbor-front public-realm programming portfolio and broader downtown-Cleveland programming infrastructure. Harbor-front public-realm programming including structured harbor-front family-amenity programming, structured harbor-front visitor-experience programming, and broader harbor-front public-realm visitor-engagement programming uses the pad as anchor public-realm programming infrastructure across operating-season programming windows. Cultural-anchor partnership programming including structured Rock and Roll Hall of Fame family-engagement programming partnership, structured Great Lakes Science Center family-engagement programming partnership, and broader cultural-anchor partnership programming uses the pad as integrated supporting programming infrastructure with structured cultural-anchor cross-programming during overlapping programming windows. Broader downtown-Cleveland programming including structured downtown-Cleveland family-engagement programming, structured downtown-Cleveland visitor-experience programming, and broader downtown-Cleveland visitor-engagement programming uses the pad as supporting programming infrastructure across overlapping programming windows. The integrated-programming framework was developed across the engagement period predating construction and is documented in the harbor-front-revitalization broader public-private partnership operating agreement. Cross-stakeholder programming coordination operates through structured monthly P3 stakeholder coordination meetings reflecting the broader harbor-front-revitalization public-private partnership infrastructure.
Replicability across other harbor-front-revitalization contexts
The North Coast Harbor model is replicable across other harbor-front-revitalization contexts where substantial public-private partnership infrastructure converges with public-realm-anchor opportunities and capital pathways supporting integrated EDA waterfront-redevelopment, state economic-development, port-authority, and master-developer P3 capital infrastructure. Analogous harbor-front-revitalization contexts where the pattern would translate include Baltimore Inner Harbor and the broader Inner Harbor public-realm portfolio, San Diego Embarcadero and the broader San Diego waterfront-redevelopment portfolio, Boston Seaport and the broader Boston Waterfront-redevelopment portfolio, Pittsburgh North Shore and the broader Pittsburgh waterfront-redevelopment portfolio, the broader Great Lakes harbor-front revitalization portfolio across Buffalo, Detroit, Chicago, Milwaukee, and broader Great Lakes waterfront-redevelopment infrastructure, the broader Atlantic seaboard harbor-front revitalization portfolio, the broader Pacific seaboard harbor-front revitalization portfolio, and the broader harbor-front-revitalization infrastructure nationally. Several conditions affect replication success. First, structured public-private partnership infrastructure across city, port-authority, master-developer, and broader stakeholder coalition is essential — harbor-front revitalizations operating without robust P3 governance face structurally different scoping frameworks. Second, capital pathways supporting integrated EDA waterfront-redevelopment, state economic-development, port-authority, and master-developer P3 capital infrastructure are uneven across revitalizations — revitalizations operating in capital contexts that constrain integrated capital pathways face structurally harder capital structuring. Third, harbor-front public-realm anchor framework infrastructure supporting integrated public-realm-anchor scoping is essential — revitalizations scoping splash pads without harbor-front public-realm anchor framework face thinner integrated-scoping outcomes. Fourth, integrated cultural-anchor partnership infrastructure where harbor-front revitalizations include retained cultural-anchor infrastructure is essential — revitalizations operating without cultural-anchor partnership infrastructure face thinner cross-programming outcomes. Where these conditions converge, the harbor-front-revitalization splash-pad pattern produces uniquely strong combined public-realm-anchor, cultural-anchor partnership, and broader harbor-front revitalization programming outcomes.
Voices from the project
“Structured public-private partnership scoping reflects the broader harbor-front-revitalization public-private partnership infrastructure across the City of Cleveland, the Cleveland-Cuyahoga County Port Authority, the master-developer partnership, and the broader harbor-front-revitalization stakeholder coalition. Every scoping decision operated through structured P3 governance frameworks, and the framework substantively shaped capital-structuring, operational-programming, and broader public-realm-anchor governance dimensions across the engagement period predating capital scoping.”
“Harbor-front public-realm anchor framework operates with the splash pad scoped as anchor public-realm infrastructure across the broader harbor-front public-realm portfolio. Structured pedestrian-flow integration connects the pad-anchor area to adjacent cultural-anchor infrastructure including the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and the Great Lakes Science Center, and the integrated public-realm-anchor framework reflects the structural significance of public-realm anchor infrastructure within harbor-front-revitalization initiatives substantively.”
“Master-developer partnership contribution through the broader public-private partnership capital infrastructure reflects the structural reality that harbor-front-revitalization initiatives operate as integrated public-private capital structures rather than as discretely public or discretely private capital structures. The integrated capital-structure framework demonstrates how P3 capital structuring operates substantively, and other harbor-front revitalizations should be benchmarking the integrated capital-structure framework.”
Lessons learned
- Operate the project through structured public-private partnership scoping reflecting the broader harbor-front-revitalization public-private partnership infrastructure across city, port-authority, master-developer, and broader stakeholder coalition; thinner P3 scoping infrastructure substantively undermines integrated capital-structuring and operational-programming outcomes.
- Scope the project as anchor public-realm infrastructure across the broader harbor-front public-realm portfolio with structured pedestrian-flow integration connecting the pad-anchor area to adjacent cultural-anchor infrastructure; isolated public-realm scoping substantively undermines public-realm-anchor outcomes.
- Pursue U.S. Economic Development Administration (EDA) waterfront-redevelopment capital pathways where the project demonstrates integrated waterfront-redevelopment public-realm-anchor infrastructure within harbor-front revitalization contexts; the program-fit narrative writes itself for harbor-front revitalization public-realm-anchor projects scoped substantively.
- Engage state economic-development capital pathways where the project demonstrates substantive harbor-front-revitalization scope; state economic-development capital pathways are structurally aligned with harbor-front-revitalization public-realm-anchor projects scoped substantively.
- Pursue port-authority capital pathways where the project demonstrates integrated harbor-front-revitalization public-realm scope; port-authority capital pathways substantively reinforce the broader harbor-front-revitalization public-realm scope dimension.
- Negotiate master-developer P3 capital contribution through the broader public-private partnership capital infrastructure; master-developer P3 contribution substantively reinforces the integrated public-private partnership capital structure and broader harbor-front-revitalization integration.
- Develop structured cultural-anchor partnership programming infrastructure where harbor-front revitalizations include retained cultural-anchor infrastructure; cultural-anchor cross-programming substantively amplifies the public-realm-anchor scope dimension across the broader operating life of the project.
FAQ
How does the public-private partnership governance operate, and what specific governance infrastructure shaped the splash pad scoping process?
Public-private partnership governance operates through several integrated governance infrastructures reflecting the broader harbor-front-revitalization P3 infrastructure. The City of Cleveland operates as the primary public-sector governance authority with structured city-council approval across capital-structuring and operational-programming decisions, structured city-administration coordination across project-management dimensions, and broader city-stakeholder consultation across the broader harbor-front-revitalization governance context. The Cleveland-Cuyahoga County Port Authority operates as a co-public-sector governance authority with structured port-authority board approval across capital-structuring and operational dimensions, structured port-authority administration coordination across project-management dimensions, and broader port-authority-stakeholder consultation. The master-developer partnership operates as the primary private-sector governance authority with structured master-developer-partnership leadership approval across capital-structuring and broader P3 partnership dimensions, structured master-developer-partnership coordination across project-management dimensions, and broader master-developer-partnership stakeholder consultation. Stakeholder coalition governance operates across the broader harbor-front-revitalization stakeholder coalition with structured stakeholder-coalition consultation across every scoping decision. Cross-governance coordination operates through structured monthly P3 stakeholder coordination meetings reflecting the broader harbor-front-revitalization P3 infrastructure.
How does the harbor-front public-realm anchor framework operate, and how does the splash pad integrate with the broader harbor-front public-realm portfolio?
Harbor-front public-realm anchor framework operates through several integrated dimensions reflecting the broader harbor-front public-realm context. The splash pad is scoped as anchor public-realm infrastructure across the broader harbor-front public-realm portfolio with structured public-realm pedestrian-flow integration connecting the pad-anchor area to adjacent cultural-anchor infrastructure including the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and the Great Lakes Science Center, structured public-realm programming integration across the broader harbor-front public-realm context, and broader public-realm-anchor visitor-experience integration. Public-realm pedestrian-flow integration operates with structured pedestrian-flow infrastructure connecting harbor-front public-realm visitor-flow patterns through the pad-anchor area to adjacent cultural-anchor infrastructure, supporting structured family-flow across the broader harbor-front public-realm context. Public-realm programming integration operates with structured public-realm programming including harbor-front family-amenity programming, harbor-front visitor-experience programming, and broader harbor-front public-realm visitor-engagement programming using the pad as anchor public-realm programming infrastructure. Broader public-realm-anchor visitor-experience integration operates across the broader harbor-front public-realm visitor-experience context with the pad operating as substantive anchor visitor-experience infrastructure.
How does cultural-anchor partnership programming operate, and what specific cross-programming dimensions reflect integration with the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and the Great Lakes Science Center?
Cultural-anchor partnership programming operates through several integrated cross-programming dimensions developed in extensive coordination with the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and the Great Lakes Science Center programming leadership. Structured Rock and Roll Hall of Fame family-engagement programming partnership integrates the splash pad with broader Rock Hall family-engagement programming through structured family-day cross-programming, structured family-experience cross-programming, and broader cross-stakeholder family-engagement programming. Structured Great Lakes Science Center family-engagement programming partnership integrates the splash pad with broader Science Center family-engagement programming through structured science-engagement cross-programming including water-and-Lake-Erie-science cross-programming, structured family-experience cross-programming, and broader cross-stakeholder family-engagement programming. Structured cross-cultural-anchor programming integrates the splash pad with broader cross-cultural-anchor programming including Rock-Hall-and-Science-Center cross-programming partnership, broader downtown-Cleveland cultural-anchor cross-programming, and broader regional cultural-anchor cross-programming. The cultural-anchor partnership programming framework reflects the structural significance of cultural-anchor cross-programming within harbor-front-revitalization initiatives that include retained cultural-anchor infrastructure.
Related reports & data
Pair this case study with our original-data reports for citation and benchmarking.