How a YMCA in Charlotte, North Carolina added a courtyard splash pad with member, day-pass, and scholarship access
A composite YMCA-branch case study of a Charlotte Y whose courtyard splash pad operates under a three-tier access model — member access, day-pass access, and scholarship access — supporting both core branch programming and broader neighborhood family engagement through the Y's mission-driven sliding-scale infrastructure.
Summary
A Charlotte YMCA branch added a $640,000 splash pad to its central courtyard as part of a $1.9M family-recreation expansion. The pad operates under a three-tier access model: full access for active YMCA members, day-pass access for non-members at $12 per family per day, and full-scholarship access for households participating in the Y's sliding-scale membership program. First-season operations documented approximately 18,400 member visits, 4,200 day-pass visits, and 6,800 scholarship visits across the May-September season. Day-pass revenue covered roughly 38% of operating costs, scholarship-supported visits represented approximately 23% of total attendance, and the three-tier structure has emerged as a meaningful balance between sustainable operations economics and the Y's mission-driven access commitments. The branch's overall family-membership recovery from a post-pandemic decline has been attributed in part to the new amenity.
Key metrics
Background: a Charlotte branch, a post-pandemic membership decline, and a family-recreation expansion vision
Charlotte's Steele Creek YMCA branch — a 1998-era facility on a 12-acre parcel in southwestern Mecklenburg County — operates as one of the regional Y's six full-service branches, with active membership of approximately 4,200 households across a primarily middle-income suburban catchment. Branch family-membership had peaked at roughly 5,100 households in 2019 and declined steadily through the pandemic period to approximately 3,400 by mid-2022 — a roughly 33% decline that branch leadership attributed to a combination of pandemic-period programming disruption, increased competition from for-profit suburban fitness facilities, and aging family-recreation infrastructure that had not been meaningfully refreshed since branch opening. Branch leadership adopted a family-recreation expansion vision in 2023 designed to address the family-membership decline through a courtyard transformation including a splash pad, an outdoor family-fitness area, an expanded shaded picnic and gathering footprint, and a refreshed children's outdoor-play area. The splash pad was identified as the most-visible amenity addition and the most-likely-to-drive family-membership recovery, with parent-survey research consistently naming summer water recreation as the highest-priority unmet family-recreation need.
Three-tier access model: members, day-pass, and scholarship
The splash pad operates under a deliberately structured three-tier access model balancing core membership-revenue support with the Y's mission-driven access commitments. Tier one is full member access, available to all active YMCA members during the pad's May-September operating season with no additional fees beyond standard membership dues. Tier two is day-pass access at $12 per family per day, available to non-member neighborhood families across all operating hours and supporting the family-recreation amenity dimension of the Y's broader community-access role. Tier three is full-scholarship access, available to households participating in the Y's sliding-scale membership program (which itself operates under a 0-50% sliding-scale structure for households below 300% of the federal poverty level) with no day-pass fees or restrictions during scholarship-eligible periods. The three-tier structure produces a layered access experience supporting member retention, day-pass revenue generation, and equity-focused access programming, with explicit operational protocols ensuring the three tiers operate as parallel access pathways rather than visibly stratified access experiences.
Capital funding and the YMCA-association capital structure
The $1.9M family-recreation expansion was funded through a four-source capital structure including approximately $850,000 from a branch-specific capital campaign supporting the family-recreation expansion vision, $400,000 from the regional YMCA association's capital-allocation reserve supporting branch facility development, $350,000 from a regional family foundation specifically tied to the splash-pad amenity, and $300,000 from a major-gifts donor with multi-generational connection to the Y. The capital structure leveraged the YMCA association's substantial capital-allocation infrastructure supporting branch facility development, which is geographically uneven across the Y's national network — Charlotte, Atlanta, Dallas, and similar Southeast metropolitan associations have substantially stronger capital-allocation capacity than thinner-resource associations. The family foundation grant supporting the splash-pad component was the most-mission-aligned funding source, with the foundation's program-staff explicitly tying grant criteria to scholarship-integrated access programming. The major-gifts donor commitment was anchored in a multi-generational relationship with the branch and emerged from a strategic donor-cultivation cycle across the 28 months of pre-construction planning.
Sliding-scale scholarship integration and the equity-focused access programming
The Y's sliding-scale membership program operates under a 0-50% sliding-scale structure for households below 300% of the federal poverty level, with households below 100% of the federal poverty level eligible for full-scholarship membership at no cost. Branch sliding-scale enrollment has historically run approximately 18% of total membership across the Steele Creek branch, reflecting the surrounding catchment's middle-income demographic but supporting meaningful equity-focused access programming. First-season splash-pad operations documented approximately 6,800 scholarship-supported visits — roughly 23% of total attendance and substantially higher than the 18% scholarship-membership share, suggesting the splash pad has produced disproportionately strong utilization among scholarship-eligible families. The branch interprets this pattern as a meaningful indicator that the amenity is effectively reaching the equity-focused population that scholarship programming is designed to support. The family foundation grant supporting splash-pad construction included an explicit operational-subsidy component supporting scholarship-related operations costs across the first three years of pad operations, ensuring the equity-focused access programming is not under-resourced relative to member-supported operations.
Operational outcomes: family-membership recovery, day-pass revenue, and scholarship utilization
First-season operational outcomes have meaningfully supported the branch's family-membership recovery vision. Branch family-membership recovered from the approximately 3,400 mid-2022 trough to approximately 4,200 by end-of-first-pad-season — a roughly 24% recovery that branch leadership attributes substantially to the family-recreation expansion overall and the splash pad specifically. Day-pass revenue produced approximately $50,000 across the first operating season, covering roughly 38% of total pad operating costs and exceeding the branch's pre-construction projections of $35,000-40,000. Scholarship-supported attendance representing approximately 23% of total visits demonstrated stronger equity-focused utilization than pre-construction projections of 15-18%, suggesting the splash pad has been particularly successful at reaching scholarship-eligible families. Operational issues across the first season clustered around peak-weekend congestion (mitigated through reservation-based weekend access for non-member day-pass holders), staff coordination across the three access tiers (resolved through dedicated front-desk training emphasizing access-tier neutrality), and seasonal-rate adjustments for day-pass pricing (the branch piloted a $9 weekday day-pass rate in late season that produced meaningful weekday utilization gains).
Replicability across other YMCA-branch contexts
The Steele Creek model is replicable across YMCA-branch contexts where established membership infrastructure, regional YMCA-association capital-allocation capacity, and supportive family-foundation infrastructure converge. Several conditions affect replication success. First, branch-specific capital-campaign capacity supporting multi-hundred-thousand-dollar fundraising goals is essential — branches without established donor-cultivation infrastructure face stronger pre-construction capital-development challenges. Second, regional YMCA-association capital-allocation capacity is geographically uneven — Charlotte, Atlanta, Dallas, and similar Southeast metropolitan associations have substantially stronger capital-allocation capacity than thinner-resource associations. Third, sliding-scale membership infrastructure supporting equity-focused access programming is essential — splash-pad amenities without scholarship integration risk replicating rather than reducing neighborhood-recreational disparities. Fourth, day-pass access pricing requires careful local-market calibration — pricing too high reduces day-pass utilization and undermines the broader-community-access role, while pricing too low reduces operating-cost coverage and pressures member-funded operations. Fifth, three-tier access programming requires substantial front-desk coordination capacity supporting access-tier neutrality across member, day-pass, and scholarship pathways — fragmented coordination produces visibly stratified access experiences that undermine the Y's mission-driven access commitments.
Voices from the project
“Family-membership had declined 33% through the pandemic period. The family-recreation expansion was a strategic bet that physical amenity refresh would drive membership recovery. The 24% first-season recovery substantially supports that bet. The splash pad is the single most-visible piece, but the broader courtyard transformation matters too.”
“Twenty-three percent of splash-pad attendance came from scholarship-supported visits — substantially higher than our 18% scholarship-membership share. The splash pad is reaching scholarship-eligible families more effectively than our broader programming portfolio. That is the mission-aligned outcome that justifies the family-foundation grant supporting scholarship-related operations.”
“Day-pass pricing was the operational question we revisited most frequently across the first season. Twelve dollars on weekends, nine dollars on weekdays, no fees on scholarship-eligible visits. The pricing structure has to balance access with operations economics — too high undermines access, too low pressures member-funded operations.”
Lessons learned
- Structure access through three-tier member, day-pass, and scholarship pathways supporting both sustainable operations economics and mission-driven access commitments — single-tier access models produce weaker combined outcomes.
- Calibrate day-pass pricing carefully across local-market context with seasonal-rate variation supporting weekday utilization — uniform pricing produces utilization gaps during off-peak windows.
- Integrate splash-pad amenities fully into existing sliding-scale scholarship programming with operational-subsidy budget support across the first three years of operations — under-resourced scholarship programming undermines mission alignment.
- Position splash-pad development within broader family-recreation expansion visions rather than as standalone amenities — broader expansion context produces stronger family-membership recovery outcomes.
- Stack capital funding across branch capital campaigns, regional YMCA-association capital reserves, regional family-foundation grants, and major-gifts donor commitments — single-source funding rarely supports multi-million-dollar family-recreation expansion budgets.
- Train front-desk and operations staff explicitly on access-tier neutrality across member, day-pass, and scholarship pathways — visibly stratified access experiences undermine the Y's mission-driven access commitments.
- Implement reservation-based weekend access for non-member day-pass holders during peak-congestion windows — open weekend day-pass access produces capacity-management challenges across high-demand summer afternoons.
FAQ
How does the YMCA prevent the three-tier access model from producing visibly stratified access experiences?
The pad itself does not differentiate by access tier — once a family enters, they use the same features, the same shaded seating, and the same restrooms. Tier differentiation happens only at front-desk check-in, where members scan their membership cards, day-pass families pay the day-pass fee, and scholarship families check in through standard scholarship-membership protocols. Front-desk staff are trained explicitly on access-tier neutrality, and the branch publishes the three-tier structure transparently to normalize the day-pass and scholarship pathways as parallel rather than secondary access experiences.
Can a family use day-pass access without ever joining the YMCA?
Yes — day-pass access is available to non-member neighborhood families with no membership-conversion requirement. Some day-pass families do convert to membership over time (the branch tracks roughly 8% conversion across the first season), but day-pass families who never join continue to access the pad on standard day-pass terms. The Y's mission-driven access commitments include broader community access regardless of membership decisions, and the day-pass pathway operationalizes that commitment for the splash-pad amenity.
What scholarship eligibility documentation is required for full-scholarship pad access?
Scholarship-eligible families participate in the Y's standard sliding-scale membership program, which uses household-income documentation reviewed during membership enrollment. Once enrolled at the scholarship membership level, families access all branch programming including the splash pad without additional documentation or fees. The branch deliberately does not require separate splash-pad scholarship documentation — adding paperwork specifically for splash-pad access would replicate the access-friction patterns the sliding-scale program is designed to reduce.
Related reports & data
Pair this case study with our original-data reports for citation and benchmarking.